Wendywu
My mum read tea leaves and palms. They were always predictive readings, and given without questions being asked by the sitters
I believe I see exactly what you mean, and I am also liking your idea more. I also agree with your observation (or prediction ) about the opposition to having a forum called "Fortune-telling" (or similar). However, this thread was started in response to another thread saying "something was missing", a good, heated, passionate debate would sure liven things up!Grizabella said:See what I mean?
You are completely correct. I am enjoying this thread a lot!Grizabella said:I thought JSNYC was just asking how it's done and making a guess how it might be done.
Aerin said:There's something to do with predicting specific events in the future - specific enough so that they can be falsified?? i.e. you can definitely be wrong.
Maybe that is the crux of the disconnect, the definition of "fortune-telling".Wendywu said:And also for me, fortune telling has to be that definite - you will so-and-so. Not, you might if the circumstances were right, or you will at some unspecified date so-and-so.
Grizabella said:Well said, Lillie. I especially like and agree with this last part:
I clicked "submit" before I meant to in the first place.
I do believe, though, that there's a heavy and unmistakable emphasis on the non-fortune telling type of readings around here, though. I've tried my best to conform and fit in but I don't prefer doing the reworded stuff. I like fortune telling and I still think we need a sub-forum for us bracelet-clanking-scarf-sporting-hoop-wearing fortune tellers. (Even though I don't always dress exactly like that.)
Caedryn said:I NEVER dress like that ...though my wife wears scarves (for the weather), bracelets, hoop earrings (at times).
~ C
Grizabella said:Wendywu, maybe over the course of time your mom just learned that predictions do work and she got brave enough to go ahead and make them specifically as she saw them in the cards without the "or this could happen instead or maybe this", which is how it's developed for me. The wavering around was me doubting my own ability to tell for sure what the cards were saying, I think, rather than trying to feel around till something hit. As I learned to trust my cards and my ability to read them, I got better at it.
What are these misconceptions to which you allude? This thread is about how to use cards for fortune telling so stating and explaining the misconceptions would certainly add value to it.Grizabella said:I think the people who are protesting having a separate forum are pointing up the need for it because it's highlighting even more the misconceptions people are having about what fortune telling even consists of.
There is nothing preventing you from starting a fortune-telling reading thread. In fact, Lillie's alethiometer thread ran into the 1,000s of posts because it was so popular. None of those posts were "trampling" Lillie for doing fortune telling.Grizabella said:Just because a faction represents fewer members doesn't make them less deserving of a sub-forum. If even games get sub-forums, what's so against fortune tellers having one where we don't get trampled underfoot by the louder voices of the group of those who don't prefer to do it?