Barleywine
Barleywine, I don't have a suggestion for Pagan decks other than what you have. However, I love my DruidCraft, it's my go to deck, but I also had trouble with the size. So, I trimmed it to the bone. First, I trimmed it including the outer and inner borders and rounding corners, but left the titles. After a couple years, I trimmed the titles and re-rounded the corners. It is wonderful and it's now a very workable size. I have small hands and I can shuffle this deck - no problem. I followed the instructions in the Tarot Trimming thread, using a Fiskars guillotine paper cutter and a large corner rounder. It was fun and gave me time with each card.
Good advice. I haven't settled on how yet, but I'm definitely going to do it.