Cardinal virtue of Wisdom/Prudence

jmd

Of the four cardinal virtues which descend to us from ancient times, three are clearly within the deck, not only in image, but in name:
  • Justice;
  • Strength; and
  • Temperance.
But what of that other important virtue - by which I of course refer to Wisdom or Prudence?

A number of cards have at different times, and by different people, been suggested.

Of especial interest is one presented by Gareth Knight in his The Magical World of the Tarot: fourfold mirror of the universe, in which, using the 'Gringonneur' deck, suggests XXI the World card as connoting Wisdom. He does this based on a clear iconographic representation of the figures within that deck, in that only four from the major Arcana have a stellated aureole: Justice, Strength, Temperance... and the World!

Another candidate has been recently presented here is II the Papesse. In a post by smleite, mention is made that 'in fifteenth-century imagery, the virtue of Prudentia (Prudence) was some times depicted as a woman sitting in a chair, holding a book in her hand, and showing it to disciples at her feet'.

Of more 'common' - but not necessarily any the more accurate - is the persistent comments that the 'missing' virtue is represented by VIIII the Hermit. Here, amongst other places, I will but point to some of the numerous 'reasons' for this card possibly being representative of Wisdom: apart from his age and very name (which may indeed connote wisdom), his staff and lantern may likewise indicate that with which one may indicate the virtue.

Also, there are some aspects which make the sequence of human Wisdom -> Wheel of Fortune all the more natural. I need only refer to, for example, part of the concluding paragraph of Montaigne's XXXIII's essay in his first Book (titled 'That Fortune is oftentimes observed to act by the rules of reason'), in which he gives as an(other) example an act which human wisdom would have prevented, but that, with the higher insight which no human previously had, was able to both seek the revenge of a death, the killing of a murderer, and the safeguarding of an important figure... 'Thus Fortune in her directions exceedeth all the rules of human wisdome'.
 

le pendu

Hanged Man

Wasn't the Hanged Man also considered by some to be Prudence? I believe that is part of the explanation of why he appears to be STANDING rather than hanging in some of the decks.

robert
 

le pendu

'Gringonneur'

I'm looking at the cards in The Encyclopedia of Tarot pgs 112-116.

The figure on the World does have the same aureole as the 3 virtues. Interesting though that she would not be displayed in the same way as the others.. it seems more like someone "forced" her into the iconography of the World card, rather than this being a Prudence card. The other cards are all full-length depictions of the virtues.

In fact, she seems more like Faith to me than Prudence. She seems to be holding a crossed scepter. The other hand appears to have an orb.

Haven't I read that the early world cards depicted the New Jerusalem? The city of God?

robert
 

le pendu

Prudence in art

In most of the representaions of Prudence that I've seen, she usually has a mirror in her hand, is sometimes depicted with two faces, and sometimes holds or steps on a serpent.

Here is a "typical" depiction;
http://www.bergerfoundation.ch/wat4/zoom_english.cgi?dia=28

A Quicktime of the room where this painting and other virtues are depicted:
http://www.uffizi.firenze.it/QTVR/sala9M.mov

another.. untypically naked:
http://gallery.euroweb.hu/html/b/bellini/giovanni/1490-99/137alle2.html

Giotto's Prudence:
http://www.abcgallery.com/G/giotto/giotto90.html

The World:
Also found this which looks very much like the world card from Toulouse, S. Sernin. c. 1096:
http://vandyck.anu.edu.au/introduction/add/med.gothic/ah243-026.html

robert
 

Rusty Neon

The Queen of Coins in the Marseilles pack has long intrigued me. She holds her denier at eye level, reflecting and meditating. It's as if it were a mirror like in Ripa's depiction of Prudence. Note, however, that I'm not suggesting that the Queen of Coins is in effect representing the cardinal virtue of Prudence.
 

full deck

Another representation of Prudentia

I've found some images associated with "Prudentia", the Roman goddess of forethought:

http://myron.sjsu.edu/romeweb/rcoins/cc15/c17r.htm

http://myron.sjsu.edu/romeweb/rcoins/c3/c3r.htm

Both are from Roman coins. I can easily see why some consider the "World" as being the descendant of Prudentia. The cornacopia did not quite make it into later "World" images found in most decks but I did find it in the "Wheel of Fortune", held by the crowned woman, sitting on top of the wheel (Gumppenberg 1810).

I should also see what else can be found under "Sophia", which is latin for wisdom. I suspect there is a ton of Catholic-related material therein.
 

le pendu

Hi Full Deck,

I notice that the coins are refering to "Providentia". Is that the same as Prudence? Could it perhaps be Providence? That might explain the cornacopia.

robert
 

full deck

Prudentia, providence . . .

Yes, Robert, it is. I checked a definition of "prudence" and got:
Prudence \Pru"dence\, n. [F., fr. L. prudentia, contr. from providentia. See {Prudent}, and cf. {Providence}.]
So I did a web search on "prudentia" which came up with the forementioned references. I take it to mean that providence and prudentia are closely related.
 

le pendu

Thanks Full Deck,

That opens up a whole new understanding of the word for me.

robert
 

lionette

Re: Prudence in art

robertmealing said:
In most of the representaions of Prudence that I've seen, she usually has a mirror in her hand, is sometimes depicted with two faces, [...]
robert

Yes, I've seen this too. I'm not clear on the symbolism. Does the mirror suggest looking into the future? Or maybe viewing the subconscious or "other" parts of self (here I'm thinking of the Minchiate where the image in mirror appears to be male)?