Yes, it seems just the case
Your post sounded like as if they are some sort of different entity. Astronomically speaking, the Moon, the planets and the Sun, they are all stars.
yeah right ... and you said you studied astronomy.
I would explain how wrong you are, but then you would probably become mystified and ask :How did we get into this , what does this have to with this thread. All I have been doing is trying to clear up some pretty way off statements you have made as .matter of fact' and then when I do , it is ME that is off topic ?
I will be brief then and say any High School kid can tell you the astronomical difference between a star, planet and a moon. But maybe it was typo and you were tying to say they are similar things astrologically ? if so , and since this part of the thread is a about the THELEMIC concept of 'Every Man and every Woman is a Star' - the difference between 'Star' and what AC consdered 'Moon energy' is very different - read up on what AC thought of the Moon energy ... even just the energy of the Moon Tarot card.
That was my feeling against your writings. Everyone knows what the Tropical astrology is.
Was not that just demonstrated that this is NOT the case ?
But they would wonder why you brought it into this thread, when we are talking about Thelemic deity, Qabalistic Worlds and human consciousness.
You bought it up (see post 106 where I answered you ), it was a passing reference to clear a point you made, then you asked more so I explained it, now you dispute with the info I offer yet again, even though it is common knowledge (for an astrologer ) ... now, you dont like the info I offered in return to your questions and you say I am OT and people would wonder why i bought this into the thread ? ? ? ?
I actually tried to get back on OT ... to the sigils and YOU bought it up again, not me .
In any case , I see it all as the work of the magician , the subject of the card in question;
ie. one part is 'finding your star' ... and I merely tried to clarify that it would be found using a sidereal system as that was what was used in the GD, AA and Thoth system (with some 'corruption' in to tropical astrology with the modern interpretation of Thoth Tarot).
There are numerous threads on this here and in GD section. perhaps reopen one of thise if you want to address this further and you feel it is too OT here ?
By the way, I think your understanding on Tropical astrology doesn't seem right. All Astrology works with stars and their positions and movements, be it Sideral or Tropical. The difference lies in whether they focus on the fixed stars positions (Sideral) or the Suns passage of the 12 zodiacal positions around the earth (Tropical).
Sorry FM, it is apparent that you dont understand the systems involved ... maybe post your questions in the astrology forum here ?
I was just wondering what was your point bringing in Tropical astrology into this thread.
I was responding to you and trying to help you clear up a misconception. Then I tried to get back on topic but YOU returned to the subject. I dont mind at all ... but it seems you do.
