Ah Raya, it's all about the accessories!
....I'm teasing, but I was thinking about your post...
I remember someone who was used to reading at psychic fairs or big-ticket places and things shiny along with dark and mysterious had the a-okay; at a Renaissance Fair, the Ye Olde Europe or Silk Roadie seemed to set the stage.
This was long ago, so I'm not certain about setting and circumstance nowadays.
I think seven-to-ten years ago when my sis and I were thinking about having a reading... for a summer afternoon, we spotted an 'open' sign right before lunch. The door was answered by a somewhat sleepy-looking person in a denim shirt and and she asked if we come back after lunch in a few hours.
She had the candles and cards ready, a bit of incense and was more 'dressed' in dark fringy stuff...I was more interested in her old greeny Thoth deck and asked how long she had used such a classic-looking deck...this was after her general predictions (you sent a note that might be misunderstood; but in a few months, the person who received it will return a more positive answer--if you were expecting money, it's likely to come in six months....etc.)...but anyways, the deck and her familiarity with it was what I liked best...I've always been impressed with well-used, shiny-with-use or faded with time...
To get this back to LB's question, I heisitate to use my gothic style decks in person---more likely the soft cards such as the Renaissance (Trevisan) or if it's nonpictorial, I'm migrating to 40-50 card Latin suited decks. I do like the Visconti and Italian older decks, but it doesn't seem to be easily understandable even in conversational readings among friends--likely it's my limitations in conveying the ideas.
My most unexpectedly fresh readings included using a half-pictorial pip-card deck, the Ancient Egyptian from Lo Scarabeo and some Asian tarots for friends...but at the time, we were visiting Egyptian exhibits at museums or eating in an Asian neighborhood.
It seemed like my friends/family like decks with pictures of some sort on every card made the reading flow better. I found these were usually an art theme deck without a strong tie to any specific story.
I think the Renaissance from Lo Scarabeo suggests friendly stories, but because they aren't heavily vested into one storyline, people react well to the pictures. And it might be also it suits my way of reading, kind of soft-spoken and conversational, not really dramatic or over-the-top.
I am interested in the Universal Fantasy for a slightly more imaginative deck with a clean look to it...or if my friendly conversation is with a quirky humor, I'd enjoy getting the "Secrets" Tarot out. But I've not had that kind of happy circumstance happen yet...
Regards,
Cerulean