I havent seen the rock opera version. That sounds promising.
In trawling the net for different decks I did find something which has quite a few images relating to the Phantom Of The Opera. The Favole tarot
http://www.interhobby.net/tarot/viCard.php3?Code=562÷ID=IC
Knave,Knight,King, queen of masks.Masquerade Scene Likeness.
King of flowers - certainly reminds me of the phantom. He is even holding a single rose!
Raoul could be seen in the card of the Devil as Raoul means of "wolf Counsell".
There are so many cards in that deck I see with links to The Phantom. Although there isnt one directly named Phantom Of The Opera I'd say the above Favole isn't far off track.
The Fool even reminds me of a young Eric!
I wasn't sure which Gothic Tarot you meant but Leilah Wendell version.
The Lovers card would be apt. The magician In The Gothic tarot of vampires would also be an idea for a lovers card.
I'm hoping I am stimulating someones inspiriation here.
The storyboard Cerulean sounds interesting! Unfortunately he wasn't speaking in French in my dream. He had a nice soothing English accent though but, became forthright with his ideas for the tarot deck.
If only I could draw what I saw in my dream!
I have seen several versions 2004,1943, listened to the version with Michael crawford in the 80's. Never seen the Rock version yet it sounds intriguing.
There is a version apparantly which I've just found Bill Nighy is in. 1990.
Thanks for your input Greg,Cerulean,Storm82,Starlightexp.
I could go on but have to head offline.