Rights once you publish
Firstly, thanks for your kind words re my deck, guys! *blush*
Before I published, I'd heard the rumour that USGS "keep" original works. The physical meaning of "keep" is kinda irrelevant to
http://goldentarot.com as the deck was produced digitally (ie, the version on my hard drive is exactly the same as the one on theirs) - so in my case it's the copyright meaning of "keep".
In my contract with US Games, I gave them the right to choose if they register it in their or my name, but my guess is it will be theirs, since they're in it for business reasons.
I had to do a bit of soul-searching before I agreed, since as an artist I've always kept my copyright and swore I'd never hand it over. But face it, as a first-time deck creator, what kind of bargaining position was I in? They'd formally offered me a contract and I was thinking about it and also waiting to see if Llewellyn were interested in making an offer too -my hope being that I'd keep my copyright with Llewellyn. As it turned out, Llewellyn gave me a (very nice) no - kindly adding that they thought USGS was more appropriate for the deck. And then Stuart Kaplan rang me personally to ask me to sign - which just blew me away, and made me realise how incredibly lucky I was to get ANY kind of offer from USGS. I am so much in awe of Kaplan's historical tarot knowledge and couldn't believe he'd taken a personal interest in my deck. So I signed.
I don't regret it at all. They only have specific publishing rights (as someone mentioned, merchandise such as cups/t-shirts etc aren't covered). If at any stage they stop publishing for a year, the contract is terminated - so it's not "forever". And as long as they're publishing, I'll be very happy. I couldn't have asked for a publisher with wider distribution - basically anyone who's interested in tarot anywhere in the world should be able to get hold of it, and it won't be prohibitively expensive.
Perhaps if it were my paintings (see
http://kattyb.com) instead of my digital collage work, I would have felt differently. There's something very physical about 'real' paintings, and although I've sold hundreds of the buggers I don't think I'd ever part with the paintings for the (unpublished) kids' books I've written. So I can understand why some tarot deck creators have a problem "handing over" their original artwork.
I decided to be realistic. If I hadn't agreed to surrender copyright, none of you would be able to buy the deck 'for real' - it would still just be screen resolution and no good for reading with.
From USGS's point of view, I can understand their commercial decision to hold copyright. For example, if the piracy thing happens again, I think they stand a much better chance of suing the offenders than I did. Also, if I held copyright - what if I changed my mind about publishing because I couldn't handle the pressure of being in the public eye? Sure, I invested a few months of my life to make the deck, but by the time it's in print, they will have invested a lot more than that. So I think it's only reasonable that they want to do whatever they can to protect their investment.
So far, I've found them to be very co-operative with usage - for example, allowing (even encouraging) me to keep running my site, even though they have the online rights to the deck.
Hope that covers all the questions?
Oh, one more - someone asked how long it took. The original deck and site took me a few months part-time while I was travelling around the world. The proper rebuild at high res (for publishing) took about 1500 hours, which is pretty close to a year of normal working hours, but I did it in 4 months. I worked 12-16 hrs/day, 7 days a week. Not because USGS insisted on such a harsh deadline, but because that's as long as I could possibly afford to avoid real, paid work. My lovely little brother supported me - he's sweet enough to think it's an important new deck, and says he's investing in the future *grin* I've kept a list and hope it at least sells well enough to pay him back one day!
Or if anyone needs a web designer, now I'm available...