Richard
Please try to follow my reasoning. I think there sometimes may be a disparity between the pip images and the PKT meanings because:
(1) The pip images are designed to illustrate the decans (and possibly other things).
(2) The meanings given in PKT Part III for the pips are traditional divinatory meanings.
(3) The traditional meanings are not necessarily compatible with the decan titles.
I don't think there is a problem with statements (2) or (3). If statement (1) is false, I would like to know which pip images are incompatible with their corresponding decans.
(1) The pip images are designed to illustrate the decans (and possibly other things).
(2) The meanings given in PKT Part III for the pips are traditional divinatory meanings.
(3) The traditional meanings are not necessarily compatible with the decan titles.
I don't think there is a problem with statements (2) or (3). If statement (1) is false, I would like to know which pip images are incompatible with their corresponding decans.