Shalott
The other night I engaged in a facinating exercise, unfortunately it was kind of a sudden inspiration so I didn't think to take notes, although I plan to do this again once my Heron Conver arrives: I laid out my Dusserre Dodal, Thunder Bay Press Conver (trying to disregard the colors as I know they aren't original), Hadar and Jodo-Camoin. For this exercise, the Dodal took on the role of "ur" Tarot, which the others were compared to, although I can't be certain that this is entirely fair. I only had room to do 3 at a time, so first I compared the Dodal and Conver, and was surprised to see how much disappered in the Conver: the like window behind Le Papesse became a canopy, the blindfold on the cupid in L'Amoureaux disappeared, the hat of the Roy de Deniers went from some fin-like thing to just an oversized hat. One of the Roynes (grr shoulda taken notes) had two windows behind her, that became some sort of cloth held up on poles. All of the Valets appear to be indoors, based on the surface they are standing on, in the Dodal, where they all seem to be outdoors in the Conver. These are the things that stand out in my mind, I'm sure there were many more little issues, other than the art itself appearing more aesthetically pleasing in the Conver, which I'm assuming has no meaning other than possibly more sophisticated techniques. (The Roy de Batons in the Dodal looked like a Gray Alien/human hybrid, whereas the Conver made him look like a person, for example.)
Then I lined the Dodal, Hadar and Jodo-Camoin up. This produced as many questions as answers. Color-wise, the Camoin absolutely shone (shined?), appearing much more historically accurate not only with the Dodal, but also what I know of the original color sheme of the Conver. (Except that Hadar went with the black earth.) But Hadar won the imagery category (lol my own little "Oscars"). He had the little window behind Le Pappesse and that Royne which one I can't recall. The Valets are indoors. The botanical imagery on the pips were much more similar when not entirely the same. It doesn't really surprise me that Camoin would follow the Conver model more closely, but if the goal of both Camoin and Hadar were trying to get back to the original model, wouldn't Dodal, being the earlier deck, be a better model? Which only then makes me wonder where did Hadar get his color scheme? In many ways, the Hadar and Camoin seem more similar to each other. It almost seemed as though they both had access to the same source material, yet they both opted to include almost the opposite ideas in their respective decks, like, after doing this, I wish they would actually work together, use Hadar's line-drawings and Camoin's colors and THEN we may really have something that could be labeled "Ur."
Incidentally, this new book Hadar is working on sounds like it goes into some detail as to what his sources were and the choices he made...I hope so as I would LOVE to see both of their bibliograpahies! (The seemingly added imagery on the Camoin, like the door on La Maison Diev, the raft thing the figure on L'Etoille is kneeling on, were these going on the assumption that these items were actually depicted at some time in the past, before the Dodal? If that's the theory he was working with, I can deal with that...but I just wish I knew!)
Any gaps you historians can help me fill in would totally be appreciated. This was quite a history lesson in itself!
Then I lined the Dodal, Hadar and Jodo-Camoin up. This produced as many questions as answers. Color-wise, the Camoin absolutely shone (shined?), appearing much more historically accurate not only with the Dodal, but also what I know of the original color sheme of the Conver. (Except that Hadar went with the black earth.) But Hadar won the imagery category (lol my own little "Oscars"). He had the little window behind Le Pappesse and that Royne which one I can't recall. The Valets are indoors. The botanical imagery on the pips were much more similar when not entirely the same. It doesn't really surprise me that Camoin would follow the Conver model more closely, but if the goal of both Camoin and Hadar were trying to get back to the original model, wouldn't Dodal, being the earlier deck, be a better model? Which only then makes me wonder where did Hadar get his color scheme? In many ways, the Hadar and Camoin seem more similar to each other. It almost seemed as though they both had access to the same source material, yet they both opted to include almost the opposite ideas in their respective decks, like, after doing this, I wish they would actually work together, use Hadar's line-drawings and Camoin's colors and THEN we may really have something that could be labeled "Ur."
Incidentally, this new book Hadar is working on sounds like it goes into some detail as to what his sources were and the choices he made...I hope so as I would LOVE to see both of their bibliograpahies! (The seemingly added imagery on the Camoin, like the door on La Maison Diev, the raft thing the figure on L'Etoille is kneeling on, were these going on the assumption that these items were actually depicted at some time in the past, before the Dodal? If that's the theory he was working with, I can deal with that...but I just wish I knew!)
Any gaps you historians can help me fill in would totally be appreciated. This was quite a history lesson in itself!