Arnie
Of course, everyone has their preferences. That's what this thread is for. These are mine, and I hope you will share yours. This is a focus on the artwork, and not any underlying system, philosophy, religion or methodology associated with the decks. I'm surely going to annoy people with my unrestrained opinions on these decks - feel free to fire one back!!!
1. Crowley/Harris Thoth. I think this is a deck that stands far above all others, bar none. The imagery to me is just sublime and surreal. This is _fine art_, in contrast to what I would consider the pop-art of Pamela Smith. Crowley and Harris left humanity with a great gift in this deck. Most decks contain one or two "stinkers" that really annoy the crap out of me, and ruin the whole experience. There are none in this deck. Every card is a masterpiece in it's own right.
2. Etteilla III Thoth (no relationship to Crowley Thoth above). Another artistically superior deck that gets no real respect - understandably because the underlying system is sparsely documented and doesn't follow RWS or other modern styles of interpretation. I don't proclaim to understand the inner workings of this deck, but I really like the imagery. I think the way the female figures are portrayed are very down to earth and are really sensual. The deck to me has a very "mystical" appearance that I dig. If asked what a tarot deck "should look like", I could easily describe the Etteilla III along side of the RWS or Swiss 1JJ.
3. Pagan Otherworlds tarot. There's a recent thread here that goes into extensive detail on this deck so I'll leave it at that. One of the few modern decks I really dig.
Honorable mentions: Deviant Moon and Tarot of the Holy Light.
1. Crowley/Harris Thoth. I think this is a deck that stands far above all others, bar none. The imagery to me is just sublime and surreal. This is _fine art_, in contrast to what I would consider the pop-art of Pamela Smith. Crowley and Harris left humanity with a great gift in this deck. Most decks contain one or two "stinkers" that really annoy the crap out of me, and ruin the whole experience. There are none in this deck. Every card is a masterpiece in it's own right.
2. Etteilla III Thoth (no relationship to Crowley Thoth above). Another artistically superior deck that gets no real respect - understandably because the underlying system is sparsely documented and doesn't follow RWS or other modern styles of interpretation. I don't proclaim to understand the inner workings of this deck, but I really like the imagery. I think the way the female figures are portrayed are very down to earth and are really sensual. The deck to me has a very "mystical" appearance that I dig. If asked what a tarot deck "should look like", I could easily describe the Etteilla III along side of the RWS or Swiss 1JJ.
3. Pagan Otherworlds tarot. There's a recent thread here that goes into extensive detail on this deck so I'll leave it at that. One of the few modern decks I really dig.
Honorable mentions: Deviant Moon and Tarot of the Holy Light.