Gardener:
1) i find the pips much more talkative without the grey borders. i agree with TemperanceAngel that you have to let go of traditional/learnt RWS standard meanings. The pips are non scenic (ie don't involve any character), I am very stupid for never having read or studied Thoth but isn't it like that in Crowley's deck?? I have tried studying Marseilles decks but I get bored and annoyed and feel extremely frustrated for not seeing any meaning in the way the decorating flowers in the cups
mean something...
Thus the Haindl pips are a very good option to the RWS pips.
2) i am planning to study Pollack's books seriously and I am pretty sure she will unlock many secrets for me... I have always heard that Haindl was not a beginner's deck and Pollack's books about it were excellent. I still consider myself pretty much of a beginner but i decided to try seriously with Haindl. I think if you are attracted to a deck, you should go for it.
3) to be honest: haven't used the trimmed deck yet. still have some minors (about the half) to trim. I plan a little "let go" ceremony before using this deck and whatever it has to say, i will listen to it, even if it doesn't make sense without books or lwb... it might be the best reading i will ever do
better sharpen my pen to write it in my journal!
Best luck to you, Gardener, and if you feel like putting the minors aside for a while: why not???
warm blessings,
Kissa
edited to add: i had the same problem than ImageMaker with this line. I decided to go according the front (the card image) instead of the back ie i still have about 1mm of that ugly grey border on the back of my cards. doesn't bother me too much, i prefered to save the pictures on the front than trim according to the back and lose some of the details (maybe?).