Hi there easternsunrise,
I have come across the idea of trickery before. Apparently, some earlier renditions of the card represent the magician as a street charlatan playing the "hide the pea" game.
The comments by "Thirteen" on the meanings section of this site (
http://www.aeclectic.net/tarot/learn/meanings/magician.shtml) talk about this duality and the idea that the magician can be a prophet or a used car salesman!
In this light, the idea of Gwydion's trickery fits better than at first appears. However, I have to say that I am with you - the magician in this deck doesn’t really look like a charlatan (or is that just an indication of how good he is
). Like you, I tend to associate this card with personal power and the ability to use words (in the sense of self-talk) to make your desires come true. Thirteen also talks about the power of words, and refers to Genesis (And God said let there be light and there was ...) - This made me think of Jean Luc Picard and his catchphrase "Make it so"! I think the magician in this deck has the same sort of aura as Picard - who is definitely not a trickster!
In my meanderings after Tarot meanings (
http://www.biddytarot.com/cards.html is another favorite site) - I have noticed that the positive side of this card seems to be much more apparent than the trickster side - I wonder if this is a sign of the times and our culture's leaning (some might even say obsession) with personal power and self-improvement? (Not that I'm against personal power, you understand, I just wonder how this card might have been interpreted in, say, the middle ages when the social order was much more structured than today and I get the feeling that people might have seen power as something that came from outside themselves, or depended on their place in the social order.)
H’mm – all food for thought!
Thanks for starting me off these threads easternsunrise. I’ve got to the majors part of my IDS – so will undoubtedly be back!