It's Time for the "Would you Rather" Game! II :-)

illyria

Tarot Mucha, and hopefully, a Ziploc sandwich baggie

The Mucha is just warmer and more vibrant for me, and I feel the artwork populates the deck with such incandescent energy. I'll need that energy to sustain me on the island.

Oh! And the Ziploc baggie is to keep the deck safe. We wants the precious to last a bit longer.
 

bonebeach

Ooh, I actually like the cooler colors of the Art Nouveau! :) I'll want to look at soothing cool colors on the desert island. I love the heat but I'll be worried about sun exposure the whole time, so I'm probably going to be reading the cards in a cave or something...
 

Le Fanu

Easy!

The Mucha - hands down. Stranded on a desert island, one wouldn't want a deck that is very samey - and the Art Nouveau is very samey. One would presumably want a deck that has 78 different pictures.

The Mucha is vibrant and varied and readable and pretty to look at. The Art Nouveau is just pretty.