zhadee
Alta, I'd never thought of getting that deck either =) Before joining AT when spotting the Pirates I'd said: "Who needs a comic style deck when there is a Thoth available?!" and turned away, disgruntled.zhadee, what a wonderful imaginative description! I chuckled when I read it. Though I doubt that I'll ever get that deck, I see your idea about the atmosphere of a deck. I like the Robin Wood as much for the warm colours she uses as anything about the art. But use Secret Tarot, cool colours, calm soothing images, when I am in Hermit mode and sick of all the emotion around me. Lately I have been using the TM Arcus Colores a lot but have not yet worked out in my mind why it reads so well for me. Usually esoteric decks just confuse me.
For me colour and atmosphere help me read because they draw me into a deck, much as the Pirate Tarot does for zhadee. But then, I am not always receptive to any given deck. Place's Alchemical works for me in the same kind of mental state as when I use the Secret, but the Fey works while feeling outgoing.
But I have been a happy member with AT, when I saw the Pirates (amongst other decks) piled up in my favourite bookstore. I looked at it and wondered why on earth should one person wish to use a themed deck. RWS is themed in a way, too. But pirates?!
I was standing there for 10 minutes, walking back and forth, talking to myself (just in my head, I hope). One pack was already opened, so I decided to ask the cards why I should get it. I pulled one card: 9 of Coins shows 3 Pirates climbing down the stairs, where there's treasure huddled up. The message in my face. No need to gape at it for half an hour, then groping for Crowley's explanation with a feeling of defeat.
The Ceccoli Tarot works in a similar way, though the images work rather like a mirror. The message is there, just a question of courage to face it. =)