I'm afraid John and Caitlin Matthews have typecast themselves because surely I was not the only one to be taken aback when I learned of this project? They do "what they do" (mythoi of Britain and Ireland) so well that they've become synonymous with it.
This Steampunk seems...quite a departure, and I don't just mean conceptually. Is there a rule that says Steampunk tarot art has to be created using digital media (more specifically, is there a rule that says it must be "wonky and amateurish" as Leikkona puts it?)
This and several other recent decks look, to me, to be direct from the 1990s. That was a fine decade, nothing against it, but I don't think it was the best from an aesthetic standpoint.
I know nothing of Steampunk culture except that it appears to use a lot of clocks and steam engines juxtaposed with late Victorian clothing styles. Maybe my lack of understanding is what prevents me from being unable to appreciate the Steampunk pattern in tarot decks. I could understand the vampire and fairies ones even if I didn't share in them.
.